Established first-choice goalkeeper Andre Onana was disregarded of Manchester United’s squad for his or her match towards Newcastle within the Premier League on April 13.
Cameroon worldwide Onana had been ever-present within the 2024/25 prime flight however got here beneath scrutiny after United’s 2-2 draw at Lyon within the first leg of the Europa League quarter-finals three days earlier.
Supervisor Ruben Amorim spoke earlier than and after the journey to Newcastle about his determination, which led to debate over whether or not deputy Altay Bayindir will retain his place for the second leg towards the Ligue 1 aspect at Outdated Trafford on Thursday (20:00 BST).
Right here’s the most recent on Onana’s prospects of returning and what’s been mentioned, together with the views of United legend Roy Keane.
🗣️ “He was okay as a result of I defined.”
Ruben Amorim explains his determination to depart Andre Onana out of the Manchester United aspect ❌ pic.twitter.com/gagvzl9eSt
— Sky Sports activities Premier League (@SkySportsPL) April 13, 2025
Will Andre Onana play for Man United vs Lyon?
Talking earlier than kick-off towards Newcastle, Amorim mentioned he wished Onana to “disconnect” and known as the psychological facet of the sport “actually, actually vital”.
The Portuguese wouldn’t verify who would begin in purpose towards Lyon after the defeat at St James’ Park, solely replying that he would “select the very best beginning 11”.
Former England goalkeeper Paul Robinson mentioned he didn’t anticipate Onana to instantly return. “The entire narrative about him doubtlessly enjoying on Thursday simply softens the blow and leaves the door open,” Robinson advised BBC Radio 5 Reside.
“He’s going to play once more in some unspecified time in the future, however you don’t take him out for one recreation and abruptly anticipate him to be on the prime of his recreation.”
Roy Keane feedback on the information that André Onana isn’t within the Manchester United squad for the Newcastle recreation 💭 pic.twitter.com/0HFE5zc9YC
— Sky Sports activities Premier League (@SkySportsPL) April 13, 2025
Ex-United midfielder Keane disagreed. “The supervisor’s made it clear that it’s for one recreation,” the seven-time Premier League winner with the membership mentioned on Sky Sports activities.
“That’s not a foul thought. [Amorim’s] hardly going to provide you with a brand new goalkeeper with such an enormous recreation arising. There’s little question in my thoughts, just like the supervisor’s mentioned, that [Onana] will play in Europe.”
Onana has began 9 of United’s 11 matches of their unbeaten Europa League marketing campaign, retaining one clear sheet.
bet365 Champions League Winners Odds – Who Are The Favourites To Win the 2025 UCL?
Will Altay Bayindir substitute Onana towards Lyon?
Turkiye worldwide Bayindir began United’s 2-1 dwelling win over Rangers and 2-0 win over FCSB in Bucharest throughout the league part.
However his probabilities of beginning once more might have been weakened by the 27-year-old’s Premier League debut to overlook at Newcastle, the place Sandro Tonali opened the scoring and the Magpies struck thrice inside 29 second-half minutes.
Altay Bayındır’s ball is intercepted by Joelinton and Bruno Guimarães is there to complete it off 🎯 pic.twitter.com/FpKEAI75uR
— Sky Sports activities Premier League (@SkySportsPL) April 13, 2025
Newcastle captain Bruno Guimaraes accomplished the 4-1 win with a composed end after Joelinton intercepted a Bayindir ball.
“It’s completely too dangerous,” Keane mentioned of Bayindir’s tried go. “On the highest stage – the actually prime gamers – it’s about your determination making.
“That primary mistake… truthfully, I can’t perceive it. If you happen to lose it there, you already know what’s going to occur. That’s simply frequent sense.”
Bayindir additionally made a mistake when he began the EFL Cup defeat at Tottenham on December 30, permitting a Son Heung-min nook to sail over him and in.
Roy Keane feedback on the information that André Onana isn’t within the Manchester United squad for the Newcastle recreation 💭 pic.twitter.com/0HFE5zc9YC
— Sky Sports activities Premier League (@SkySportsPL) April 13, 2025
Why was Andre Onana dropped by Man United?
Onana endured a testing build-up to the sport at Lyon, with OL’s former United midfielder Nemanja Matic utilizing his press convention to name the previous Ajax common “one of many worst goalkeepers in Man United’s historical past”.
The 29-year-old made errors for each of the targets he conceded within the match, together with one to permit Rayan Cherki to equalise with the final kick of the sport.
His whole of eight errors within the Premier League since arriving from Inter for £47.2 million in July 2023 is the worst of any goalkeeper to have performed within the division since his arrival, in accordance with TalkSPORT.
“He’s definitely beneath stress,” noticed Keane. “If you happen to’re a goalkeeper and also you make a mistake that results in a purpose, you’re going to be criticised.
LYON WITH A LATE GOAL! 💥
Andre Onana’s save is spilled right into a harmful space and Rayan Cherki makes no mistake ⚽
📺 @tntsports & @discoveryplusUK pic.twitter.com/63a9d5BJs1
— Soccer on TNT Sports activities (@footballontnt) April 10, 2025
“He’s carried out OK within the league. United defensively, really, haven’t been too unhealthy. The massive drawback goes ahead – they don’t rating sufficient targets. The ‘keeper has made some large errors and been punished for it.
“Goalkeeper’s an enormous place and also you don’t wish to be rotating. It’s good to provide the ‘keeper a few days off to recharge the batteries bodily and mentally.”
Andre Onana Man United stats
Onana has saved 23 clear sheets in 94 United appearances, together with 10 in 43 video games this season whereas conceding 56 occasions.
He received six trophies with Ajax between 2018 and 2022, together with a hat-trick of Dutch titles beneath supervisor Erik ten Hag, who would signal him after turning into United boss.
Onana additionally received the Coppa Italia and Supercoppa Italiana with Inter, in addition to reaching the 2022/23 Champions League last.
Andre Onana received’t wish to see that once more 🫣
A present from the United keeper and Studying old-boy Matej Vydra pounces to place Plzen forward 😱
📺 @tntsports & @discoveryplusUK pic.twitter.com/fHlsdddhgp
— Soccer on TNT Sports activities (@footballontnt) December 12, 2024
Altay Bayindir stats
Bayindir has made 166 profession appearances and saved 53 clear sheets, together with one in eight video games since becoming a member of United from Fenerbahce for £4.3m in September 2023.
United’s first ever Turkish participant received the third-tier title in his homeland with MKE Ankaragucu in 2017 and the Turkish Cup with Fenerbahce in 2023.